Norfolk Public Schools • on the journey to world class Norfolk Public Schools • on the journey to world class Norfolk Public Schools • on the journey to world class Norfolk Public Schools • on the journey to world class Norfolk Public Schools • on the journey to world class Norfolk Public Schools • on the journey to world class

SCHOOL BOARD OF THE CITY OF NORFOLK

Minutes of the Monthly School Board Meeting
July 18, 2007

REORGANIZATION OF THE SCHOOL BOARD

The School Board convened the meeting at 3:40 p.m. in the School Administration Building, located at 800 E. City Hall Avenue, in Norfolk, Virginia.  Present were:  Chair Bishop, Vice Chair Rhodes, Mr. Cook, Dr. McCluney, Dr. Tonelson, and Dr. Wright.  Mr.  Driggers was absent.  Chief of Staff Young, Chief Academic Officer Boone, and Deputy Clerk Stocks were present.    Mr. Mungo, and Mr. Cloud was present from the City Attorney’s office.   

Dr. Melinda Boone called the meeting to order at 3:40 p.m. and opened the floor for nominations for Chairman of the School Board.  Mr. Cook nominated Mr. Bishop and his motion was seconded by Mrs. Rhodes.  The motion was voted upon and passed unanimously.

Dr. Boone turned the gavel over to Mr. Bishop who called for nominations for Vice Chair.  Dr. McCluney nominated Mrs. Rhodes and her motion was seconded by Mr. Cook.  The motion was voted upon and passed unanimously.

EXECUTIVE SESSION—CLOSED

The School Board went into executive (closed) session at 3:50 p.m.

It was duly MOVED and seconded that the members of the School Board go into closed session for the purposes set out in clause 1 of subsection (A) of section 2.2-3711 of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act, as amended:

(2)

Discussion or consideration of prospective candidates for employment, assignment, appointment, promotion, performance, demotion, salaries, discipline, or resignation of specific officers, appointees, or employees of the Norfolk Public Schools including consideration of the personnel docket of this date.

(3)

Discussion or consideration of disciplinary matters concerning students in Norfolk Public Schools, specifically the pupil personnel docket of this date.

(7)

Consultation with legal counsel and briefings by staff members, consultants, or attorneys, pertaining to actual or probable litigation, or other specific legal matters requiring the provision of legal advice by counsel.

A roll call vote was taken on the motion and it was approved unanimously.

The Board came out of closed session at 4:50 p.m. and the School Board recessed for a dinner break. 

FORMAL OPEN SESSION

Dr. Boone introduced Mr. Bishop as Chair of the School Board and Mrs. Rhodes as Vice Chair. 

Mr. Bishop called the formal session of the meeting to order at 5:35 p.m. in Room 1202 of the School Administration Building.   Present were Chair Bishop, Vice Chair Rhodes, Mr. Cook, Dr. McCluney, Dr. Tonelson, and Dr. Wright.   Mr. Driggers was absent.

Also present were Chief Officers Young, Boone, Schmitt, and Sullivan, Executive Directors Jones, Lassiter, O’Konek, and Thomas; and Deputy Clerk Stocks.   

RESOLUTION CERTIFYING AN EXECUTIVE CLOSED SESSION

It was MOVED and seconded that whereas, the School Board of the City of Norfolk convened a                         closed meeting on this date pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance   with the provisions of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and whereas,
Section 2.2-3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by the School Board of the City of Norfolk that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; now, therefore, be it resolved by the School Board of the City of Norfolk:

That the School Board of the City of Norfolk hereby certifies that, to the best of each member’s knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed, or considered by the Board.

A roll call vote was taken on the motion and it was approved unanimously.

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

Mr. Bishop led the assembly in the Pledge of Allegiance.

INTRODUCTION OF NEW ADMINISTRATORS

Dr. Patricia Dillard, Senior Director of Human Resources introduced the following new administrators:

  • Lisa A. Harris, reassigned from Assistant Principal, Lafayette-Winona to Senior Coordinator, Foreign Language, Leadership and Capacity Development
  • Tracey Flemings, promoted from Assistant Principal, Norview Middle to Principal, Rosemont Middle
  • Michelle Williams-Moore, promoted from Assistant Principal, Northside to Principal, Lake Taylor Middle
  • Sherri Archer, promoted from Assistant Principal, Larchmont to Principal, Camp Allen
  • Dr. Phyllis Clark-Freeman, promoted from Assistant Principal, Tanners Creek to Principal, Poplar Halls
  • Cheryl Jordan, promoted from Assistant Principal, Sherwood Forest to Principal, Sherwood Forest
  • Dwana White promoted from Assistant Principal, Ingleside to Principal, Ingleside
  • Monica Robinson promoted from Teacher, Booker T. Washington High to Assistant Principal, Lake Taylor High
  • James Kirk promoted from Dean of Students, Lafayette-Winona to Assistant Principal,  Lake Taylor Middle
  • Sheila Saunders promoted from Dean of Students, Rosemont Middle to Assistant Principal, Norview Middle
  • Doris Langhorne promoted from Dean of Students, Northside to Assistant Principal, Northside
  • Marcia Brown promoted from Teacher, St. Helena to Assistant Principal, Ingleside
  • Candiase Driver promoted from Instructional Specialist, Coleman Place to Assistant Principal, Camp Allen
  • Julie Honeycutt promoted from Instructional Specialist, Willoughby to Assistant Principal, Lindenwood
  • Celeste Jones promoted from Teacher, Campostella to Assistant Princpal, Tanners Creek
  • June Lightfoot promoted from Teacher, Lindenwood to Assistant Principal, Larchmont (not present)
  • Albert Balingit promoted from Senior Network Engineer, Information Division to Network and Engineering Services Administrator (not present)
  • Dr. Michael L. McIntosh elected Middle School Principal, Madison Career Center
  • Jerry Jones elected Senior Coordinator - Contractor Supervisor, School Plant Facilities
  • William Reed elected Assessment Coordinator, Strategic Evaluation, Assessment and Support

CITIZEN COMMENT ON AGENDA/NON-AGENDA ITEMS

  1. Mrs. Ginny Bobby, regarding special education reorganization (notes attached)
  2. Mr. John Fellowes, regarding special education for Autistic children
  3. Mrs. Margaret McDowell, regarding educating teachers about needs of special education children
  4. Mr. Andrew Sacks, regarding special education reorganization
  5. Mr. Peter Cardoza, regarding special education reorganization
  6. Mrs. Victorial Makhlous regarding the testing process for special education and Title I
  7. Mrs. Laurie D’Angelo, regarding differences between Title I and non-Title I schools
  8. Ms. Muriel Hecht, Chairman of the Special Education Advisory Council, regarding special education 

DISCUSSION AND APPROVAL OF THE CONSENT AGENDA

The Consent Agenda was presented for approval and contained the items listed below:

  1. The minutes for the May 23 Recognition Ceremony, the June 30 School Board meeting, and June 27 closed session to evaluate the superintendent;
  2. The June 2007, Bills and Payroll Report;
  3. The Personnel Report and Supplement
  4. The Pupil Personnel Docket for June 20, 2007, with the following items:   the Suggested Long-term Suspensions with Special Conditions report, the Long-term Suspension Report for the month of June 2007;
  5. The June Use of School Facilities Report;
  6. A school rental request from New Life Providence Church for the use of Richard Bowling Elementary School for religious services;
  7. A school rental request from Bethlehem Missionary Baptist Church for the use of Jacox Elementary School for religious services;
  8. A school rental request from Mt. Herman Baptist Church for the use of Lafayette-Winona Middle School for religious services;
  9. A motion to appoint the Clerk—Vincent A. Rhodes, Deputy Clerk—Sandra J. Stocks, Agent—Dr. Stephen C. Jones, and Deputy Agent—Frederick Schmitt of the Board for FY 2008.

The motion was made by Dr. Tonelson and seconded by Dr. McCluney to approve the consent agenda.  The motion was approved unanimously.  .

FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS AND STATEMENT

It was moved by Mr. Cook and seconded by Dr. McCluney to receive and file the June financial highlights and preliminary year end close for 2007.  The motion was approved unanimously. 

Mr. Schmitt reported on the close of the fiscal year revenues from all sources.  During the month of July Norfolk Public Schools uses a 13th accounting period where both the previous and the current fiscal years are open.  This 13th accounting period allows all prior year transactions to post to the records.  At the close of the 13th accounting period a “2007 FINAL” revenue and expenditures report will be provided.  Although somewhat of a tumultuous year, total revenue from all sources came in $32,467 lower than anticipated.

As of June 30, 2007, we have obligated or encumbered $ 309,662,655. or 99/98% of received funds.  The books closed in the black by $56,045.  This compares to 99.9% at the same time last year and 97.7% in 05.

CUSTOMER SERVICE INITIATIVE UPDATE

Mrs. Yvonne Young, Chief of Staff, presented the second update report to the School Board prepared by Regina Davis, Community Engagement Coordinator.  The recommendations for making our schools customer friendly were undertaken this year by the implementation of several professional development opportunities for clerical staff and training for administrators.  Four training sessions were conducted on Exceptional Customer Service and Time Management, 2 sessions on Customer Service I, and 2 sessions on Exploring Attitudes with 542 employees registered to attend and 469 attending.  Continuous training sessions (Stephen Covey—Putting First Things First—Habit 3) and half-day sessions offered on four different days concluded with 299 employees registered to attend and 239 attending.  Training was provided for administrators at the January Administrators’ Conference. 

The Customer Service Handbook was distributed during the year and the district four-part telephone greeting was implemented.  Secret Shopper results of district phone greeting were done in May with 82% of front-liners using the appropriate greeting.  The 17% who did not use the appropriate greeting were informed of expectations and instructed as to where the greeting was found in the handbook.

The Professional Senate had three meetings themed around Customer Service and they agreed to be ambassadors of customer service. 

The report recommended continuing using “Secret Shopper” for the district telephone greeting and to update the status of audit recommendation; conduct a survey evaluation on the effectiveness of the handbook; use the existing checklists that are in the handbook; create a video that demonstrates acceptable customer service for principals to use during in-service training, and develop a rubric for customer service awards.

NOTES FROM THE CUSTOMER SERVICE DISCUSSION

  1. Mr. Cook commented that customer service should not be taken lightly
  2. Dr. Tonelson inquired whether a video handbook would be a viable way of offering video training to new employees.  Mrs. Young replied that she cannot see video training replacing hands-on training and Mrs. Rhodes concurred.
  3. Dr. Wright asked how feedback from the Secret Shopper was evaluated. 
  4. The Board agreed with Mrs. Rhodes that recognition is needed for those who do well and the board should be informed
  5. It should be relayed that the Board expects all to offer good customer service
  6. Best practices should be identified and shared with other schools.
  7. Does the current parent survey ask parents whether they feel welcome in their child’s school?
  8. Dr. Tonelson felt that some NPS web pages are easier to negotiate than others.  As a part of customer service, he would like to see this improved.
  9. The board agreed they would like to see some employees recognized for good customer service at the first SB recognition ceremony in October (24th)

STUDENT CELL PHONE POLICY

Mrs. Yvonne Young reported to the School Board the Superintendent’s Student Cabinet recommendations made at the June 1, 2007, joint meeting with the School Board.  The purpose of the meeting was to allow the students to share their research on the student cell phone policies from the surrounding school districts.  As a result of their review and discussion, the student cabinet proposed revising the cell phone policy as described below:

  • No cell phone use during school hours (including arrival on school grounds)
  • Use during after-school activities allowed at discretion of coach/sponsor or responsible staff member
  • Exceptions may be approved in advance by principal; exceptions should be communicated to staff.  (Perhaps a cell phone pass could be issued.)

Students who violate the policy could have the phone confiscated to be picked up at the end of the day for a first offense, picked up by a parent for a subsequent offense, or picked up at the end of the year with the student losing cell phone privileges for a third offense.  (Schools would not be liable/responsible for the phone).  Continued violations would result in subordination discipline infractions.

The policy would apply to secondary schools.  Students who volunteered to talk to the Board about the cell phone policy were John Ehlers of Granby, Jenana Ferguson of Norview, Julian Parker of Norview, Darrelle Anderson of Lake Taylor, and Brittany Knaggs of Booker T. Washington.

NOTES ON CELL PHONE POLICY DISCUSSION

  1. The Board would like to get additional input from principals
  2. Mr. Cook feels the policy should include all electronic devices
  3. The board agreed any change in the cell phone policy should reduce the number of violations rather than increase them
  4. Dr. Wright was concerned about asking Coach/sponsor of after-school activities having additional responsibility of approving after-school use of the cell phone,  added to their duties
  5. All agreed that additional information/feedback should come from the administration regarding the policy
  6. Mr. Cook asked what the principals do in schools for teacher use of cell phones.

SPECIAL EDUCATION REORGANIZATION UPDATE

Dr. Boone introduced Dr. Joan Anderson, Senior Director of Special Educational Services.  Dr. Anderson explained that during the 2005-06 school year, the Department of Special Education Services initiated a reorganization designed to provide greater focus on student achievement and instructional support for academic and behavioral needs for students with disabilities.  The goal was to be accomplished through increased access to the general education curriculum, aligned professional development based on data, and restructured central system support for teachers, principals, and schools.  The report provided an update on the efforts associated with the reorganization and results of the state’s Federal Program Monitoring.  Mary Beers, principal of Crossroads Elementary School answered questions from the board about the impact of the change in schools and preparation principals are under taking for the new students.

NOTES FROM SPECIAL EDUCATION REORGANIZATION DISCUSSION

  1. Dr. Boone requested that the complete special education Powerpoint presentation be sent to the Board.  The version in the board packet was not complete.
  2. Sent copy of original special education reorganization report to board members for background.
  3. Dr. Tonelson asked whether with the reorganization we are doing more with less resources.  Dr. Anderson responded that staff was being reallocated and services were covered.
  4. Mr. Cook asked about who (what classification of students) were being moved and Dr. Anderson responded grades K-5, LD, ADHD, some autistic.
  5. Mrs. Rhodes felt she needed more background to understand the different needs.
  6. Dr. McCluney asked what the makeup was of people who took part in the data gathering.  Dr. Anderson responded that the department worked closely with the Strategic Evaluation, Assessment, and Support department (SEAS); principals; sub-committees; and parents.
  7. Mr. Cook asked where do students travel from to attend the Granby Elementary School Autism classroom and Dr. Anderson replied she would have to get back with him on the answer.
  8. Dr. McCluney wanted to know the timeline for implementation
  9. Dr. Tonelson wanted to know to what degree the timeline is followed and why were parents informed so late in the year.  He also wanted to know whether teachers were provided an in-service to become familiar with the needs of special education students. 
  10. Dr. McCluney wanted to understand the role parents played in the planning and asked that Dr. Anderson explain it to her after the meeting.

2007-2008 PROPOSED PAY SCALES CLARIFICATION

The School Board received a report from Jane Pellegrino clarifying the pay scales stipend for teachers.  In order to attract new teachers to NPS, the Board approved a one-time incentive for hard-to-fill positions (math, speech pathologists, and school psychologists) in an amount not to exceed $2,000 per teacher during the May School Board meeting.  This incentive would be paid (50%/50%) at the completion of the first semester and the close of the school year.

This incentive would be for new hire math and school psychologists, but be provided to all speech pathologists (39).  The cover sheet on the pay scales approval sheet noted it would be paid only to new hires.  However, it had been the intention to provide the stipend to all speech pathologists since NPS spent over $500K on contracted services last year to provide these mandated services.  The cost benefit to provide the stipend in hopes of attracting permanent staff is compelling.

APPOINTMENT OF SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS TO FILL COMMITTEE ASSIGNMENTS FOR THE 2007-08 SCHOOL YEAR

Mr. Bishop asked whether anyone wanted to change their committee assignments and there were no changes. 

Dr. McCluney and Mrs. Rhodes agreed to serve as the Recognition Committee, stating they would like to come up with ideas on how best to recognize community members.

Mr. Cook agreed to be the School Board liaison to the NRHA.

Dr. Tonelson agreed to sit on the Community Services Board.

The members agreed to talk about the pros and cons of assigning the same two board members to attend all LAP meetings during the school year at the School Board retreat in August.

OTHER SCHOOL BOARD MATTERS

  1. Committee Reports
  2. Other Items of Interest:

Mr. Bishop went over the new format for meetings that will be implemented at the September 19th School Board meeting:

4:00pm – 5:30pm — Open Informal, CR 1200
5:30pm – 6:30pm — Closed, CR 1200
6:30pm – 7pm — Dinner Break for Board
7pm – 8:30pm — Open Formal, CR 1202 

He also stated that board meetings are on the NPS web site under the School Board section.
           
It was noted that the August retreat dates conflict with vacation days for board members and Dr. Wright and Mrs. Rhodes asked that we look into having the retreat in July next year.  Dr. Wright stated she would be able to come back from her vacation to attend the August retreat, but Mrs. Rhodes will not be able to attend the retreat at all.  Mr. Cook will not be able to attend the Saturday session.

Dr. Wright asked Dr. Dillard to write a letter to top-of-scale teachers informing them of the School Board’s decision to pay them a bonus in appreciation of service.  The $1,000 bonus will be paid in two parts--$500 in December and $500 in May or June.  
 
The meeting adjourned at 8:06 p.m.

Minutes approved by the School Board:   August 15, 2007